Without name-checking every track, there are a decent number of enjoyable tunes on the record. 'When She Comes Home' is a snail-paced trawl through the last unexplored corners of Neil Young's back bedroom, while 'Choir Of Angels' welcomes a hint of Appalachian country charm - but crucially not enough to make it a remotely happy song. From soft, lazy beats and 70s-hued guitars, there's a sufficiently retrospective feel to ensure a perception of successful time travel.
A similar impression can be gleaned from McCauley's gravel-beaten vocals, which put politely, appear to have been nabbed from a much older fellow - someone at least thirty years his senior. Middle-range notes that would pose no obstacle to you nor I prompt one eye-watering strain after another. By the excruciating chorus of 'The Sad Sun', listeners will be fighting the urge to force Strepsils through the stereo's headphone jack, for fear of him coughing up a kidney.
Having said all that, some of the album's most affecting moments simply wouldn't have weight in the absence of McCauley's cord-splintering howl. 'Goodbye, Dear Friend' is a tear-jerking ode to the pains of love and loss with no more than a solitary, sentient piano, to carry its morbid sentiment. A track that will invariably stick in the mind and prove difficult to move beyond, it echoes the deathly themes ringing through 'Choir Of Angels', 'Christ Jesus' and, in fact, most of the record.
The problem is that, in presenting a dearth of anything vaguely cheerful or upbeat, an album's components can only be judged on a scale of maudlinness and misery. Given that this is the case, certain songs on The Black Dirt Sessions are bound to pale by comparison - even though, on any regular LP, they would represent a poignant rest-stop to punctuate the joy of other offerings. Here, there is no joy, except perhaps for the sadistic pleasure in knowing that - if what McCauley writes has any basis in truth - whatever your problems, he's much worse off.
'The Black Dirt Sessions' was released on July 5, 2010.









